In nearly all of his (and his ministry team’s) letters, the Apostle Paul opens the letter with a formal thanksgiving section:
This thanksgiving section was actually a common feature of Greco-Roman letter writing outside of Christian correspondence. The sender would offer thanks to the gods for the health and wellbeing of the recipient and their families. Here’s an example:
Dionysius to Hephaistion greeting….When I received your letter, in which you made clear that you had come safely through great danger and that you were being held fast, for this, that you are well, I gave thanks to the gods. (Letter35 (P.Vat.Gr. 2289) in Light from Ancient Letters)
We could conclude then that Paul simply includes the thanksgiving as a mere formality. But when we read the letters in their entirety, we realize that Paul’s thanksgivings may mean something a bit different from just standard greetings. Look at how Paul describes the nature of Christian thanks:
First, Paul instructs believers to “give thanks in all circumstances” (1 Thess 5:18). Unlike thanks that are offered only for good health, success, and prosperity, Paul and his team emphasize thanks as equally appropriate in unfavorable circumstances. In 1st Thessalonians, Paul and his team offer comfort to those grieving the death of fellow members. Life is not only a divine gift, but God’s presence and sovereignty in death is as well.
Second, Paul reframes suffering thus: “But thanks be to God, who in Christ always leads us in triumphal procession, and through us spreads in every place the fragrance that comes from knowing him” (2 Cor 2:14). What’s really interesting is that Paul is actually talking about the fragrance of death—an aroma that the world associates with defeat but that Christians should associate with Christ and therefore victory. Because the crucified Jesus has been raised from the dead by God, suffering and death for the faithful, then, are certain to lead to glory.
All this makes sense considering what the ultimate thanksgiving celebration is in the church: the Eucharist. “Eucharist” means thanksgiving in Greek, and it is this word that the church chose to describe their celebration of the Lord’s Supper or Holy Communion. In his last supper with his disciples, Jesus both declared his impending suffering and offered thanks to the Lord. As believers celebrate this meal, we likewise identify with Jesus’s suffering as well as trust in God’s faithfulness.
As we come to our holiday time of Thanksgiving here in the United States,I wonder what it would look like for us to embody Paul’s kind of giving thanks? What would happen if we went around the dinner table and gave thanks in all the circumstances—including the challenges, the hardships, and the heartache weexperience? What if we looked at every inconvenience and difficulty as an opportunity to grow more like Jesus? That in itself would be something worth celebrating.